What is the purpose of education?
Hello Bloggers!
It is lovely to
return to blogging again, it has been a while. Today’s blog poses the question,
what is the purpose of education? Each educational professional will have their
own perspective of this and adopt their own pedagogical beliefs however, this
blog will focus on not only others beliefs but also my own.
For me, the
main purpose of education is to allow children to become the best versions of
themselves in the present and future. Chapman (2015) argues that it is assumed
that a person’s wellbeing is the result of what they do and that school is a
place that prepares students for the future labour markets, however, I disagree
with this. Particularly within the early years, it is vital that schools
promote and teach about health and wellbeing, in order for pupils to live happy
and healthy lives which will one day impact their learning.
The official rationales for formal state
education outlines the governments intended purposes of education. Government
state that education ‘gives people more and better life and career
opportunities’ and also ‘helps to make a therapeutic use of their leisure time’
(Moore, 2002). Therefore, the aim of the government is not to prepare students
to pass assessments but to ensure that children within schools have a good
quality life both now and in the future.
I believe in
primary education specifically in the early years that, before teaching and
learning about the world or about cultures, education should teach children
about themselves and their own health and wellbeing. It is important to
highlight wellbeing within the classroom, as if students are not healthy or
happy, no learning can take place. Goswami (2004) provides evidence for this,
as it has been identified that when students are anxious or stressed within
school it affects part of the brain called the frontal cortex which affects
student’s judgements and responses.
Noddings (2003)
argues that ‘happiness should be an aim of education and a good education
contributes to personal and collective happiness’ which enhances students
learning. There is an increasing need for more focus on wellbeing in schools as
in today’s society, there is a growing number of children suffering with mental
health issues, statistics show that 5% of children from as early as five to
sixteen years old have been diagnosed with a mental illness however, a further
70% of children experience issues but have not received appropriate support
from an early age (Mental Health Foundation, 2017). Mental health issues will
hinder student’s education, as they may become absent from school or become
stressed and anxious which affects learning. Therefore, a child’s education is
disrupted. The picture below, are the reception students in my placement enjoying their time in physical education, which is allowing them to work together, relax and enjoy their learning.
In terms of
pedagogy, I believe that the teaching of health and wellbeing can be overlooked
as, due to the demands of the curriculum and national tests, teachers adopt the
pedagogical beliefs that they should only be preparing students to do well in
tests. Therefore, teachers are teaching more facts as opposed to allowing
students to work together and discuss issues (Moore and Edwards, 2000). In
order to create ambitious, capable learners (Donaldson, 2015) students must be
engaged and willing to learn, which can only happen if schools are ensuring
that learner’s wellbeing is supported.
Wellbeing is at
the forefront of the Australian curriculum and their pedagogical beliefs
(Hamilton and Redmond, 2010). The
Department for education in Australia (Australian Government 2000-2003) have
found that ‘students with higher levels of wellbeing, tend to have better
cognitive outcomes’ this affecting academic achievement. In order to ensure the
wellbeing of students in schools in Australia, they have created the notion of
safe schools, free from harm and risk which teachers work together to promote.
Safe school also links to students feeling emotionally safe. Students are
reassured that the school can also support their emotional needs. Australia put
these services in place as their National Mental Health Reform (Australia
Mental Health Plan, 2009) showed that school was an effective place for early
intervention, to help students with mental health. A study of Australian
schools interviewed teachers about wellbeing and how policy
helped to promote wellbeing. An important response from one teacher stated that
wellbeing is not something that can be promoted through policy but wellbeing is
the connectedness of a school, it is the relationships that a safe school
offers students to enable them to listen and confide in the people around them.
The study also highlighted Australia’s bullying policy that helps teachers to
take steps in order to resolve bullying as soon as possible, but teachers also
highlighted the needs for a wellbeing policy that would help them to promote wellbeing
in their schools. As Australia look for ways to improve their already
beneficial approach to wellbeing, the UK are still behind.
In the UK
section ten of the Children’s Act 2004, places schools responsible for
working together with local authorities to improve the wellbeing of students
within schools. If the UK, were to adopt Australia’s pedagogical approach and
hold the same emphasis on wellbeing there could be a decrease in absence due to
mental health issues. Providing emotional support within schools may also allow
the numbers of children affected by mental health issues to decrease. Finally,
promoting health and wellbeing in schools makes for happier and healthier
students that will be more engaged in learning.
References
Australian
Government Department of Health and Family Services. (2000). A national
framework for health promoting schools (2000-2003): National health promoting
schools initiative. Retrieved from http://www.chpcp.org/resources/health%20promoting%20schools%20framework.pdf (Accessed: 15.11.17).
Chapman, A.
(2015). Wellbeing and schools: Exploring the normative dimensions. In J. McLeod
& K. Wright (Eds.), Rethinking youth wellbeing (pp. 143–160). Singapore:
Springer.
Donaldson,
G. (2015). Successful Futures: Independent review of curriculum and
assessment arrangements in Wales. Caerdydd: Llywodraeth Cenedlaethol Cymru.
Goswami, U.
(2004). Neuroscience and education. British
Journal of Educational Psychology, 74, pp. 1-14.
Hamilton, M.,
& Redmond, G. (2010). Conceptualisation of social and emotional wellbeing for
children and young people, and policy implications. Sydney: Social Policy
Research Centre.
Mental
Health Foundation (2017) Mental Health Statistics: children and young
people. Retrieved from: mentalhealth.org.uk (Accessed: 15.11.17).
Moore,
A. (2000) Teaching and Learning: Pedagogy, Curriculum and Culture. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Moore, A. and
Edwards, G. (2000) ‘Compliance, Resistance and Pragmatism in Pedagogic
Identities.’ Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the American
Educational Research Association, New Orleans, 24–28 April 2000.
Noddings,
N. (2003) Happiness and Education. Cambridge: Cambridge
University.
Powell,
A et al. (2017) 'Examining the policy-practice nexus', Wellbeing in schools, pp. 222-225.
As you stated early on in your blog I noticed that you believe that the early years setting should promote health and well being for children, rather than preparing them for future employment. However both the current Welsh curriculum and Donaldsons review both want to prepare learners for the uncertain future. Do you believe there should be a balanced mix between both.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I do agree with your view as people are growing up the percentage of obese and sedentary individuals is increasing also with an increase of suicides.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Rhys, thank you for your comment.
DeleteYes, I believe that there should be a balance between preparing students for the future and promoting health and well being. In order to prepare students for the future, students have to be in a position where they are able to engage and learn effectively in school. As I have highlighted in my blog Goswami (2004) shows that if the well being of students is not ensured that they will not be in a position to learn therefore schools will not be able to prepare students to be the future workforce. I also see the importance of health and well being greater when considering the link between students and their future. I have included Mental Health Foundation Statistics (2017) in the blog, that look at current levels of mental illness within young children. Mental illness sufferers usually suffer issues for a very long time, without seeking help. If help is not provided in schools, then students will continue to suffer until later in life including at work. This links to Donaldson's ambition to create ambitious, capable learners, students suffering with mental illness may lack ambition for the future and as Goswami suggests will not be capable learners.
I completely agree that rising numbers of children suffering with obesity and mental illness' is concerning. Therefore schools must promote health and well being to enable these numbers to decrease.
Thank you again for taking the time to read my blog!